My Idea Online
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
Wednesday 29 March 2023
  • Login
  • News and Society
  • Automotive
  • Business
    • Business
    • Communications
    • Employment
    • Finance
    • Legal
    • Home Based Business
    • Marketing
    • Online Business
    • Product Reviews
    • Real Estate
    • Self Improvement
  • Home and Family
    • Home and Family
    • Family
    • Home Improvement
    • Kids and Teens
    • Reference and Education
  • Lifes
    • Arts and Entertainment
    • Cancer
    • Entertainment
    • Food and Drink
    • Fashion
    • Health and Fitness
    • Humor
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Recreation and Sports
    • Writing and Speaking
    • Women’s Interests
  • Online
    • Computers & Internet
    • Site Promotion
    • Web Development
  • World Affairs
No Result
View All Result
  • News and Society
  • Automotive
  • Business
    • Business
    • Communications
    • Employment
    • Finance
    • Legal
    • Home Based Business
    • Marketing
    • Online Business
    • Product Reviews
    • Real Estate
    • Self Improvement
  • Home and Family
    • Home and Family
    • Family
    • Home Improvement
    • Kids and Teens
    • Reference and Education
  • Lifes
    • Arts and Entertainment
    • Cancer
    • Entertainment
    • Food and Drink
    • Fashion
    • Health and Fitness
    • Humor
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Recreation and Sports
    • Writing and Speaking
    • Women’s Interests
  • Online
    • Computers & Internet
    • Site Promotion
    • Web Development
  • World Affairs
No Result
View All Result
MyIdeaOnline.com
No Result
View All Result

Can you proceed with a disciplinary hearing when the employee concerned is off sick?

idea online by idea online
in Legal
3 min read
2k 125
0
law

law

1.2k
SHARES
2.6k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


In this month”s Cripps Alert we look at two recent cases on disciplinary procedures. Both cases occurred before the new statutory disciplinary and dismissal procedures came into force in October 2004, but still provide useful guidance on these matters.
Can you proceed with a disciplinary hearing when the employee concerned is off sick?
The first case concerned the increasingly common problem of what to do when an employee facing disciplinary charges goes off sick. It is common in our experience at the first sign of disciplinary action being taken against an employee for that employee to leave work and head immediately to their GP”s surgery where they get a sick note for “stress and anxiety”. The employer is then left with a dilemma – should they proceed with the disciplinary hearing without the employee present or put the matter on hold until the employee returns to work? The recent case of William Hicks & Partners v Miss G Nadal is a caution to employers who are tempted to ignore medical opinion and proceed with the disciplinary hearing without the employee.
Miss Nadal, a personal injury solicitor, was suspended following allegations of misconduct and bullying made against her by a secretary in her team. During her suspension, Miss Nadal experienced stress and went to her GP. He signed her off sick and confirmed that, in his view, she would continue to suffer from stress for “the foreseeable future”. Despite receiving this letter, the firm decided to go ahead with the disciplinary hearing “in order not to exacerbate her stress.” Miss Nadal responded by saying that she would be unfit to attend the hearing on the date proposed, but anticipated that she would be fit within two weeks. The firm postponed the disciplinary hearing for about a week and sought to ascertain when Miss Nadal was likely to be fit to respond to questions at a disciplinary hearing and, in the alternative, if she was fit to make written submissions. Miss Nadal”s GP confirmed that Miss Nadal would not be fit to attend the hearing on the re-arranged date and neither was she fit to provide written representations.
Meanwhile, Miss Nadal was in negotiations with the firm over a compromise agreement and was also in the process of securing alternative employment.
The hearing was re-arranged once more but the firm refused Miss Nadal”s request for a further postponement. The firm wrote to her stating that they did not accept that she was not medically fit to attend the hearing or put her case in writing and further, they felt it was important to the staff who had made the complaints that the matter was dealt with quickly. The hearing went ahead and Miss Nadal was dismissed. She started work with a new firm the following week.
The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) held that the employer”s decision to go ahead with the hearing without Miss Nadal being present was not within the range of reasonable responses and was therefore unfair. The EAT did not allow Miss Nadal”s employers to rely on the negotiations over the compromise agreement and Miss Nadal”s acceptance of a new job as sufficient to override the doctor”s opinion (that she was unfit to attend the disciplinary hearing) and the general rule that an employee should always be present at a disciplinary hearing.
The EAT in this case took care to stress that proceeding with a disciplinary hearing without the employee, particularly where dismissal may be the result should occur only in exceptional cases. They gave as an example the situation where an employer makes proper enquiries, including medical enquiries to establish that the employee is fit and able to attend the disciplinary hearing. If such enquiries suggest that the employee is fit to attend the hearing but the employee still refuses to attend without good reason, the EAT were of the view that the employer could go ahead without the employee. Such cases will be rare. This case is a warning to employers to make every effort to establish an employee”s state of health before deciding to proceed with a disciplinary hearing in their absence.

Tags: Legal
idea online

idea online

The internet makes it easy to start a business but what should you start? Discover the right business for you to start with our definitive list of the best online ideas

Related Posts

law

The Known Advantages of A Living Trust

3 weeks ago
108service 1

Accident Injury Claim – Get The Right Solicitor To Succeed

3 weeks ago
Things 9 scaled

Where’s an Attorney When You Need One?

1 month ago
lawyer

PERSONAL INJURIES IN COMMON CARRIER ACCIDENTS

1 month ago
law

Recognizing “Abuse” May Be Key Step for Many Immigrants Seeking Green Cards

1 month ago
lawyer88

Google’s Book Scanning and Laws

1 month ago
No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • A School Loan Consolidation Primer
  • 10 Ways To Make More Money In Network Marketing
  • Web Site Promotion: Getting Exposure For Your Promotional Articles
  • Media Savvy – How To Lead, Persuade, And Influence
  • The importance of having a feedback form in your e-commerce website
  • Repair And Maintenance Of Kitchen Faucets
  • A Sign Or Just A Rainbow?
  • Why You Should Eat Lentil Soup at Least Once a Week
  • Impotence
  • Things You Should Know About Vitamin K’s Unique Power
  • How To Write eBay Auction Descriptions That Get Bids
  • What is Compost Tea?
  • How To Dramatically Increase Your Clickbank Sales Now
  • A Nostalgic Flashback Of The 1950s Era
  • Baby Strollers – Consider Your Budget
  • บริษัท
  • โรงเรียน
  • ก่อสร้าง
  • บริการ
  • กฏหมาย
  • ท่องเที่ยว
  • พนัสนิคม
  • ผู้ผลิตสินค้า
  • อิเลคทรอนิคส์
  • ราชการ
  • ไทย

© 2020 myideaonline.com - property for rent - property for sale.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Online Idea Content
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2020 myideaonline.com - property for rent - property for sale.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In